Learn
A little clarity for your next decision.
Loading your learning library…
Investor WorkspaceWelcome, there!Log Out
Investor WorkspaceA little clarity for your next decision.
By Jerry Baker
A DST return forecast shows what a set of assumptions would produce, not what you are promised to earn. Cash-on-cash, equity multiple, and internal rate of return measure different parts of the result. To compare them, use the same cash flows, dates, fees, and sale assumptions, then test what happens if the plan falls short.
A percentage is incomplete without a definition. Is it a past payment rate, a future estimate, a property-level return, or the investor's return after costs? Does it cover one year or the full life of the investment?
I want to know what the number includes before deciding what it means. A polished chart does not answer that question. Request the calculation and the source of each major input.
The SEC distinguishes actual results from targets, projections, and back-tested results. It also advises investors to review fees, methods, market conditions, and missing information. Past success does not establish what a new investment will earn. [1]
The examples below are invented math exercises. They explain how metrics work and are not forecasts for a DST, a sponsor, or an investment strategy. Actual investments can lose money, stop making payments, and remain illiquid for years.
For a simple annual calculation, divide cash distributed during the year by the equity invested. A hypothetical $100,000 investment that pays $5,000 during a full year has a 5% cash-distribution rate on that starting amount.
That calculation does not tell you whether the property gained value. It does not show what you will receive at sale. It also does not establish whether every dollar paid came from current property operations.
Ask what funded the payment. Rent after bills is different from returning investor capital or using other sources. FINRA's private-placement guidance cautions firms against presenting distributions that include returned principal or borrowed funds as investment yield. The composition matters, not just the check amount. [2]
Confirm the denominator, too. A rate based on original investor cash is not the same as a rate based on a current estimated value. A partial first year is not a full year of results. Keep those details beside the percentage.
Suppose a hypothetical $100,000 investment pays $2,500 during six months. The cash actually received is 2.5% of the starting amount. Doubling that figure produces a simple 5% annualized rate, but the investor has not received a full year's payments.
That distinction becomes important when the first payment covers a partial month or includes several months at once. Use the period the payment represents. Do not assume a large first check establishes a new monthly rate.
When reading a statement, separate actual cash through the reporting date from an estimate for the rest of the year. If a rate assumes payments continue unchanged, say so. Review later payments before treating that assumption as a result.
The same caution applies to a short holding-period gain. A very large annualized figure from a brief period can distract from the actual dollars, one-time events, and risks involved. Look at the full record and dates together.
For a completed investment with no extra contributions, add all cash distributions and final net sale proceeds. Subtract the initial amount to find the cash profit or loss before personal taxes. Divide all cash returned by the initial amount to calculate the equity multiple.
Suppose you invest $100,000 and eventually receive $135,000 in total. The cash profit is $35,000, the total return is 35%, and the equity multiple is 1.35 times. These are three ways of describing related dollar amounts.
A 1.35 multiple does not mean a 135% profit. The total includes the original money that came back. Nor does it mean a 35% annual return. You still need the dates to understand the pace of the result.
If the investment remains open, ask whether the multiple includes an estimated remaining value. An appraisal or model value is not cash received. Label a combined realized-and-estimated figure clearly, and do not compare it with a finished cash result without that distinction.
Internal rate of return, or IRR, is the rate that makes the present value of the investment's cash paid and cash received balance to zero. It is a money-weighted measure: both the amount and timing of cash matter. It is not a time-weighted return. [2]
In plain English, IRR uses the whole cash-flow schedule rather than one year's payment. The starting investment goes in as money paid out. Later distributions and net sale proceeds go in as money received.
For equally spaced annual cash flows, an annual IRR calculation uses one row per year. Actual investments often pay on uneven dates. A date-based calculation, often called XIRR in spreadsheet software, can account for those dates. Check which method was used.
An annualized result is not a promise to pay that rate every year. It is also not a bank balance that compounds at that rate. How you spend or reinvest payments affects your separate household results.
Here is a hypothetical investment with one initial payment and cash received at the end of each year. Assume no personal taxes and no additional costs outside the listed amounts. The final row includes the last regular payment plus net sale proceeds.
| When | Investor cash flow | What it represents |
|---|---|---|
| Start | −$100,000 | Initial investment |
| End of year 1 | $5,000 | Cash distribution |
| End of year 2 | $5,000 | Cash distribution |
| End of year 3 | $5,000 | Cash distribution |
| End of year 4 | $5,000 | Cash distribution |
| End of year 5 | $115,000 | $5,000 distribution plus $110,000 net sale proceeds |
The investor receives $135,000 in all. That gives a 1.35 equity multiple and a 35% total return. The annual IRR is about 6.75%. Each full year's $5,000 payment equals 5% of the initial cash.
Dividing 35% by five gives a 7% simple average annual return. That arithmetic is valid for that definition, but it is not the 6.75% IRR. Do not switch labels because two results happen to look close.
This example has no remaining asset value after year five. If a statement still included a value for the sold asset, adding it again would overstate the result.
Keep the total cash returned at $135,000, but change when it arrives. If all $135,000 arrives at the end of year five, with no earlier payments, the annual return is about 6.19%. The multiple remains 1.35.
Now assume $15,000 arrives after year one, $5,000 at the end of each of years two through four, and $105,000 at year five. The total is still $135,000, but the annual IRR is about 7.29%.
The higher IRR reflects earlier cash in this example. It does not prove that the investor made more total dollars. It also does not tell you whether the early payment was income or returned capital.
Compare both measures with your needs. If you must pay current bills, timing matters. If your goal is long-term growth, the final dollars matter too. Neither measure tells you how much risk was taken to obtain them.
Return to the first example, but reduce net sale proceeds from $110,000 to $70,000. Keep the five annual payments of $5,000. The investor receives $95,000 in total against a $100,000 initial investment.
The cash result is a $5,000 loss before personal taxes. The multiple is 0.95, and the annual IRR is about negative 1.14%. Regular 5% cash payments did not prevent a loss over the whole hold.
This is why I do not evaluate a DST by a payment rate alone. I also want to understand the loan balance, property condition, future leasing costs, and what might remain after sale.
A forecast can miss in the other direction as well. A better sale or stronger operating cash flow could improve results. Neither direction should be assumed simply because the spreadsheet includes a precise percentage.
Start at the property. Review rent from actual leases, expected vacancies, concessions, unpaid rent, and other income. A signed lease is not the same as cash collected. A forecasted renewal is not yet a signed lease.
Subtract operating expenses such as property taxes, insurance, utilities, repairs, and management. Then identify items outside that operating subtotal, including debt service, capital work, trust costs, and reserves. Use the definitions in the model so expenses are not missed or counted twice.
For an original arithmetic example, $1 million of property income after operating expenses, less $600,000 of debt service, $150,000 of capital and reserve funding, and $50,000 of trust costs leaves $200,000. That is before any other applicable items.
If an investor has a 1% share of that distributable amount, the example produces $2,000. On a $100,000 investment, that is 2%. A property-level income figure of $1 million alone would not have told you the investor's cash rate.
The OCC's lending guide reviews cash flow, debt coverage, market risks, and repayment together. Those are useful economic checks, even though the guide is written for banks rather than DST investors. [3]
Principal payments reduce the loan balance. All else equal, a smaller payoff leaves more cash when the property sells. But the principal payment also used cash that could not be distributed at the time.
Suppose a hypothetical property sells for $10 million. Its debt fell from $6 million to $5 million during the hold. Before selling costs, $5 million remains after the final loan payoff.
The benefit of the $1 million principal reduction is already reflected in that $5 million. Adding another $1 million of “debt paydown return” to the sale proceeds would count the same benefit twice.
Some loans pay interest only for part or all of the term. Do not build automatic principal reduction into those periods. Use the actual amortization schedule and confirm whether the final payoff includes other charges.
Debt can magnify losses as well as gains. A projection that uses leverage should be reviewed with its payment terms, maturity date, and downside cases. A higher modeled return does not make the loan risk disappear.
A model often estimates sale value by dividing a future year's net operating income by an assumed exit cap rate. Check which year's income it uses. Also check whether that income is based on signed leases, hoped-for growth, or unfinished work.
With $900,000 of annual net operating income, a 5% cap rate implies $18 million. A 6% rate implies $15 million. The same income supports very different values under those two assumptions.
If debt at sale is $10 million, gross equity before costs is $8 million in the first case and $5 million in the second. The property-value difference flows through to equity after the debt is repaid.
This is not a forecast of cap rates. It is a way to see how sensitive the math can be. The OCC discusses the links among income, capitalization rates, value, and interest-rate conditions. [3]
Subtract selling costs and other obligations before using the result in investor returns. Ask whether a delayed sale would change the loan payoff, reserves, and costs. Moving the date alone may not capture the actual effect.
Ask whether the initial cash amount includes the full price you pay, including offering costs. Ask which property, sponsor, financing, and sale costs are already reflected in the later cash flows.
The SEC explains that transaction charges and ongoing expenses both reduce returns. A product-level figure can also omit account or advisory costs that apply separately to you. Read the offering disclosures and your account fee schedule together. [4]
If you pay $100,000 and some of that funds disclosed costs, your personal starting cash outflow is still $100,000. Do not shrink it to only the amount applied to property equity to make the return look better.
At the same time, do not subtract a fee twice. If it was already paid from property cash before distributions, it is already reflected in those cash flows. Keep a short record of where each fee enters the model.
A pre-tax return is not your after-tax result. Depreciation, your basis, suspended losses, state rules, and the exit structure can change taxes. A model based on another investor's tax facts may not describe yours.
Qualifying DST owners are treated as owning their share of the underlying property for federal income tax purposes under the facts in Revenue Ruling 2004-86. Their tax items need to be analyzed accordingly. That does not mean all cash distributions are tax-free income. [5]
Have the CPA build a separate tax estimate with the timing of payments and tax bills. Label it clearly. Do not add an assumed tax deferral to investment profit as though it were a cash distribution from the property.
Inflation matters too. A flat dollar payment buys less if your costs rise. A positive nominal return can still fall short of your spending goals. Keep a household budget beside the investment model instead of asking one percentage to answer both questions.
First change one input at a time. Try lower collected rent, slower lease-up, higher insurance, or a larger repair bill. This shows which assumptions have the most effect on cash available to investors.
Then combine related problems. A tenant departure could mean lost rent, leasing costs, a longer vacancy, and a weaker sale price. Treating each as an isolated event may understate the strain.
Include financing and timing. An interest-only period may end before the sale. A delayed exit can require more cash for operations. Review the actual loan terms rather than assuming a later sale simply adds another year of steady payments.
A stress test is not a probability estimate unless a supported probability model is used. It also is not a forecast that the downside stops at the cases shown. The purpose is to expose fragile assumptions and missing cash needs.
Ask which risks the structure can address. Revenue Ruling 2004-86 places important limits on the trust's powers, including debt changes. A spreadsheet remedy such as “refinance and renovate” may require a different legal structure and tax review. [5]
Use a comparison sheet with rows for investor cash, full acquisition costs, payment dates, debt terms, operating assumptions, sale costs, and final proceeds. Record the source and date of each item.
Then compare the same metrics over the stated periods. A completed investment, an open investment with an estimated value, and a new proposal are three different evidence levels. Do not put them in a single ranking without explaining the difference.
Ask about omitted results in a sponsor's history. The SEC warns that selected strong periods or successful investments can paint a misleading picture. Market conditions during the prior hold also matter. [1]
A higher projected result might come from lower costs or stronger cash flow. It might instead come from a lower exit cap rate, more debt, or a shorter assumed hold. Identify the cause before treating the difference as an advantage.
FINRA Rule 2210 generally prohibits performance predictions in member communications, with specified exceptions. Its math-illustration exception does not permit forecasting a particular investment or strategy. Calling a number “hypothetical” is not a universal exemption from the rule. [6]
That is one reason this guide explains invented cash-flow math instead of providing a return target for an offering. The firm's review of any actual materials is a separate process. An article about reading models is not approval of a model you receive.
Also check the calculator itself. Uneven dates, the wrong sign on a payment, a missing contribution, or a double-counted final value can distort results. Some unusual cash-flow patterns can produce more than one IRR or no useful single answer.
When the output looks surprising, go back to the dated cash ledger. A clear record of dollars paid and received is more useful than a confident-looking percentage you cannot reproduce.
No. IRR is money-weighted and reflects cash-flow amounts and timing. A time-weighted measure uses a different method. Use the proper label so results can be compared on the same basis. [2]
No. The payment rate does not capture the final sale result or prove that every payment is operating profit. Review all cash paid, cash received, dates, and costs before calculating the full return.
Yes. A multiple measures total dollars relative to invested dollars. IRR also responds to when the money arrives. Earlier cash can raise IRR without increasing total dollars received.
Not when those proceeds already use the reduced loan payoff. Doing so counts that benefit twice. Principal payments affect operating cash when paid and the loan balance remaining at sale.
No. It reflects assumptions rather than a completed result. Review the operating plan, fees, debt, exit value, and less favorable cases. Actual results may be much worse, including a loss of principal.
Request each definition, dated cash-flow schedule, fee treatment, hold period, and exit assumptions. Ask whether figures are actual or hypothetical and whether remaining property values are estimates. Keep liquidity and risk in the comparison.
Do not assume it does. Your tax outcome depends on your facts and the transaction. Have your CPA show those effects separately, without treating deferred tax as property income or guaranteed extra return.
Educational information, not an offer or a personal tax, legal, or investment recommendation. Examples are hypothetical and omit stated adjustments. Tax treatment depends on your facts and current law. Review your transaction with your CPA, attorney, and qualified intermediary. Real estate investments can lose value and may be illiquid.
Enter your approved email to explore investments, save your shortlist, and keep learning.