Learn
A little clarity for your next decision.
Loading your learning library…
Investor WorkspaceWelcome, there!Log Out
Investor WorkspaceA little clarity for your next decision.
By Jerry Baker
REITs and DSTs can provide real estate cash flow in retirement, but neither promises a paycheck that lasts for life. A useful comparison starts with the income you need, the cash you can reach, and the losses your plan can absorb. Listed REITs, non-traded REITs, and exchange-oriented DSTs have different roles in that plan.
A distribution rate is not a retirement plan. Before comparing investments, list the money your household needs after tax. Separate basic bills from spending you could delay. Include irregular expenses such as home repairs, travel, dental work, and help for a family member.
Then list the income that is already expected from sources such as Social Security and a pension. Use what reaches your bank account after tax and deductions. The gap between that income and planned spending is the amount your assets must support.
For example, assume a household plans to spend $72,000 per year and expects $36,000 of net income from other sources. Its portfolio must cover a $36,000 annual gap, or $3,000 per month. That is the target to test. It does not become smaller because an investment brochure shows a high yield.
The CFPB treats retirement planning as a balance among income, assets, and debt, with a need to plan for future financial help. That whole-household view matters more than choosing an investment based only on its payment schedule. [1]
A REIT is a company that owns real estate, finances it, or holds related assets. Some REIT shares trade on a stock exchange. Others are registered but non-traded. Private REITs are another category, with their own offering terms and access rules. [2] [3]
A listed REIT normally gives you a market in which to sell shares. It does not give you a fixed sale price. A non-traded REIT may have a limited repurchase program, but its terms can cap, delay, or suspend payments. A private REIT may offer even fewer ways to leave.
A DST used for a 1031 exchange usually holds a defined property or portfolio under a trust agreement. Investors rely on the manager and the trust's permitted actions. They generally should not expect a market that lets them withdraw part of their money on demand.
Do not combine all of these under a single “passive real estate” heading in your cash plan. They may each reduce hands-on work while giving you very different access to your capital.
Income is money an investment pays you. Liquidity is your ability to turn the investment into cash. You may need both, but one cannot automatically stand in for the other.
Suppose a DST distributes enough for routine bills, but a large care expense arises. The trust may own valuable property and still offer no practical way to return your principal that month. An estimated sale date is not your personal withdrawal date.
With a listed REIT, you may be able to sell enough shares to meet the bill. If the shares have fallen in price, doing so may lock in a loss and leave fewer shares to support future spending. The ability to sell is useful; the price still matters.
With a non-traded REIT, do not assume a submitted repurchase request will be paid in full. Read the current plan, including limits, deductions, eligibility, and the board's powers. A stated net asset value is not a guaranteed cash offer for every shareholder. [3] [4]
Make a simple twelve-month calendar. Place known bills in the month they are due. Place expected investment payments in the month cash should arrive. Mark any payment that depends on a sale, refinancing, or manager decision.
A monthly payment can feel more like a salary than a quarterly payment. Frequency does not make it safer. A reserve can also turn uneven property receipts into smooth investor payments for a time. Ask where the money comes from, not just how often it arrives.
Include personal tax payments in the calendar. The entire distribution is not necessarily available to spend. Taxable income and cash paid can differ, so a bank balance alone does not tell you how much to reserve for taxes.
If a projected payment is late, the mortgage, grocery bill, and insurance premium still come due. A cash calendar makes that mismatch visible before it becomes an urgent request to sell an illiquid interest.
Consider the household with a $36,000 annual spending gap. For a teaching example, assume it has $300,000 in a DST and $300,000 in listed REIT shares. This is not a suggested allocation. A real retirement plan should review all assets, income, debts, and risks.
Assume each investment pays 5% of its original investment for the year, or $15,000. Those rates are hypothetical and net of all investment-level ongoing costs. The starting balances are after any purchase costs. There are no new account fees, and the example assumes sale charges are zero; actual charges would reduce cash.
For easy budget math, reserve 20% of each payment for combined personal taxes. This is an invented effective tax assumption, not a statutory rate or a claim that DST and REIT income receive the same tax treatment. It leaves $12,000 to spend from each investment.
| Annual budget item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Household spending gap | $36,000 |
| Net DST cash after assumed tax | $12,000 |
| Net REIT cash after assumed tax | $12,000 |
| Remaining amount to fund | $12,000 |
The investments pay $30,000 before personal tax, but the household still needs $12,000 after applying the assumed tax reserve. If it sells $12,000 of REIT shares, that sale is a withdrawal of capital, not another dividend. The tax on any share-sale gain or loss must be assessed separately; assume no current sale tax for this isolated example.
That distinction prevents a common mistake: calling all money withdrawn from a portfolio “income” and then assuming the original capital remains intact.
Now reduce the DST's gross annual distribution by 30%, from $15,000 to $10,500. Keep the REIT distribution unchanged solely to isolate the effect. At the same assumed 20% personal-tax reserve, DST cash falls to $8,400.
Total spendable distributions are now $20,400. The household must fund $15,600 of its $36,000 gap from another source. That is $3,600 more than in the base example.
At the same time, assume the listed REIT position has fallen 30%, from $300,000 to $210,000, before any capital withdrawal. Selling $15,600 uses about 7.43% of that reduced position. The earlier $12,000 withdrawal was 4% of the original $300,000.
These are capital-withdrawal percentages, not safe withdrawal rates. The example does not predict price changes or distributions, and it does not assume the DST kept its market value. Both investments could suffer at once.
When losses occur early and you keep withdrawing money, fewer assets remain to take part in a recovery. That is the practical concern often called sequence-of-returns risk. An investment that does not quote a daily price can still lose value; a quiet statement does not remove the loss.
A reserve should have a job. It might cover a gap between quarterly distributions, a temporary cut, or a large known expense. Its size should reflect the household's actual needs, not a universal rule copied from another retiree.
In the example, a separate $24,000 reserve would cover two years of the original $12,000 annual shortfall if no other demands arose. Under the stress case, it would cover about 1.54 years of the $15,600 shortfall. Those simple divisions ignore interest and taxes on the reserve and assume spending does not rise.
The reserve is separate from the $600,000 invested. It is not counted twice as both investment capital and available cash. If there is no separate reserve, the plan must say where the money will come from.
Also distinguish your household reserve from cash held inside a DST or REIT. Property reserves may be restricted to repairs, loan requirements, or other business needs. They are not a personal checking account you can draw on.
Ask whether payments are supported by property operations or come partly from reserves, borrowing, offering proceeds, or asset sales. These sources have different effects on future earning power. SEC guidance discusses why the source and sustainability of non-traded REIT distributions deserve close review. [4]
A high distribution can coexist with falling capital value. Suppose you start with $100,000, receive $6,000 over a year, and finish with an investment worth $90,000. Your combined cash and ending value is $96,000 before personal tax and any uncounted exit costs. The 6% cash payment did not prevent a 4% total loss.
For a DST without a ready sale market, the ending value may be uncertain. That makes it harder to measure a current total return. It does not justify assuming the original investment amount is still fully recoverable.
Ask for the current operating results, the reserve balance, debt terms, and the bridge from property cash flow to investor payments. A forecast should include repairs, capital needs, fees, and debt service. If the payment rests on optimistic refinancing or sale assumptions, it may not belong in the same budget line as a reliable outside income source.
A DST acquired in a qualifying exchange can defer gain from investment real estate, subject to the ruling's facts and all other exchange rules. REIT shares ordinarily do not serve as direct replacement real property for that exchange. Choosing listed shares after a property sale may therefore require a separate taxable-sale plan. [5] [6]
That starting tax difference matters, but it does not establish which choice best supports retirement. Include future taxes, fees, access to capital, and investment losses. Do not assume every dollar deferred is a permanent addition to spending money.
For REIT shares in a taxable account, year-end tax reporting may divide payments among ordinary dividends, capital-gain distributions, and return of capital. Return of capital generally reduces basis; it is not simply free income forever. Further amounts after basis reaches zero can produce gain. [7]
A DST investor's taxable income can differ from cash distributions because of depreciation and other tax items. The investor's carryover basis affects depreciation after an exchange. Your accountant should calculate that schedule rather than using the sponsor's cash distribution as the taxable-income figure. [8]
A taxable-account investment payment and a required minimum distribution from a retirement account are different events. Cash from a personally held DST does not by itself satisfy a traditional IRA's withdrawal requirement.
Likewise, a REIT dividend retained inside an IRA is not automatically a distribution out of the IRA to its owner. The account must complete the required withdrawal under the applicable rules. Account type, ownership, and beneficiary status matter. [9]
Ask the custodian and tax adviser to identify which accounts have required withdrawals, how much is due, and where the needed cash will come from. Do not assume an illiquid holding will sell just because the account has a tax deadline.
Aggregation rules differ among account types. The IRS allows certain IRA withdrawals to be combined, while many employer-plan requirements must be met separately. A broad statement such as “I took enough money out somewhere” can miss the actual requirement. [9]
Retirement spending does not stay still. If a $36,000 gap grew by an assumed 3% per year for ten years, it would become about $48,381. That is hypothetical compound math, not an inflation forecast. A flat $24,000 of net investment cash would cover less of that future need.
Rents may rise, but higher rent does not guarantee higher investor payments. Property taxes, insurance, repairs, wages, and loan costs can rise too. Lease terms may limit rent changes or delay them. A manager may also retain more cash for future needs.
REIT management may change the portfolio over time. A DST may have narrower powers under its trust agreement. Neither approach assures that net income will keep pace with the cost of living. [2] [5]
Revisit the budget when health, housing, family duties, or other income changes. The best plan at retirement may need revision years later. A long hold should be measured against those possible needs, not just against today's tax bill.
Owning both a REIT and a DST does not automatically diversify the household. They may own similar apartments in the same markets, depend on the same major tenant, or face similar borrowing risks. Your home and any remaining rental property add more real estate exposure.
Look through the names to the properties, tenants, regions, and debt. Diversification can help manage risk, but a narrow fund or several similar holdings may leave the same main risk in place. [10]
A listed position can often be trimmed when the mix changes, though price and tax consequences matter. A DST position may remain in place until the manager's exit. A non-traded REIT may not honor the entire repurchase request when you want to rebalance.
That means the liquid part of the portfolio may have to absorb most withdrawals and adjustments. Test whether it is large enough to do that after a market decline. Do not assume an equal starting split stays equal once one side must fund all extra cash needs.
Retirement planning includes the chance that someone else may need to handle your finances. Keep a clear list of accounts, contacts, tax records, payment schedules, and transfer limits. Explain which assets can be sold and which require a longer process.
Have an estate lawyer review authority to act, ownership, and beneficiary arrangements. A family member who knows your wishes may still lack the legal authority to sign. A trusted contact is not automatically a power of attorney.
For a DST, include the governing documents and the latest reports. For a REIT, include the brokerage or custodian records and, if relevant, repurchase terms. The person helping you should not have to infer access to cash from a line on a statement.
The CFPB's retirement resources emphasize planning for future financial decisions and help as people age. Making the plan understandable is part of making it usable. [1]
Ask what each investment is meant to do. Is it part of an exchange, a source of flexible withdrawals, a long-term real estate holding, or a piece of a larger income plan? Then ask what it cannot do.
A DST may fit capital you can leave invested through an uncertain hold. Listed REIT shares may offer access that helps manage withdrawals, while exposing you to market prices. Non-traded REITs require their own review of fees, valuations, and repurchase limits. None is a substitute for a household plan that survives lower income and unexpected expenses.
Write down what you would change if payments fell, a sale were delayed, or costs rose. The answer should be something you can do without relying on an investment to provide a right it never promised.
Keep one more distinction clear: cash paid out for spending cannot also compound inside the same investment. If a projection assumes every distribution is reinvested, it does not describe a retiree who uses those payments for bills. Ask for a second projection with your actual withdrawals and their dates. That version may show a very different ending balance even if the investment performs exactly as assumed.
There is no reliable answer based only on the structure. Compare net cash after investment costs and personal tax, the source of distributions, the risk of cuts, and access to capital. A higher quoted payment can come with more risk or less flexibility.
No. A projected distribution depends on investment results and the governing terms. It can change or stop, and capital can be lost. Treat it as investment cash flow and test how the household would respond to a shortfall.
No. Listed shares trade in a market, but their price can fall. Non-traded and private REITs can be illiquid, and any repurchase plan may have limits. Identify the type of REIT and read its actual terms before counting it as accessible cash. [2] [3]
No. Frequency tells you when a payment is scheduled, not whether operations can support it. Ask whether the payment uses recurring property cash, reserves, borrowing, or returned capital. A smooth schedule can hide uneven underlying results.
Ordinary REIT shares do not qualify as direct replacement real property. Certain DST interests can qualify under the relevant facts and exchange rules. Have your tax adviser review the actual interest before you commit exchange proceeds. [5] [6]
No. A required minimum distribution is a withdrawal from the relevant retirement account under its rules. A payment from an asset held personally outside that account does not replace the required account withdrawal. Coordinate the account-level requirements with the custodian. [9]
Base that decision on known bills, other income, possible cuts, and the time needed to access each asset. There is no one reserve size that fits every retiree. Keep personal reserves separate from cash held inside a property investment.
Test lower distributions, a market decline, and an unexpected bill at the same time. Identify which assets would fund the gap, how much must be sold, and what would remain. A plan should work through a difficult period without assuming every asset can be sold promptly at its stated value.
Educational information, not an offer or a personal tax, legal, or investment recommendation. Examples are hypothetical and omit stated adjustments. Tax treatment depends on your facts and current law. Review your transaction with your CPA, attorney, and qualified intermediary. Real estate investments can lose value and may be illiquid.
Enter your approved email to explore investments, save your shortlist, and keep learning.